
The story in 5 beats
- Move over
A small ship appears out of a time distortion and asks the captain to step aside. Picard does, and a tall man materializes where he stood.
- The historian
Professor Rasmussen says he has come from the 26th century to observe this exact moment. Picard checks his credentials, and they seem in order.
- Penthara IV
Phasers drill into the planet to release carbon dioxide and trap heat. It works, until the drilling sets off quakes and volcanoes.
- Tell me what happens
Picard asks Rasmussen whether the last-ditch plan will work. Rasmussen refuses: it could change his own history.
Search the podSpoiler · tap to reveal
Rasmussen is ready to leave, but things have gone missing from the ship. Data goes into the pod to look.
Why it still matters
Matt Frewer, still best known as Max Headroom, plays Berlinghoff Rasmussen, a self-described visitor from three centuries ahead who hands the senior staff questionnaires, pokes around their quarters and asks Data for his schematics. The part was written for Robin Williams, who couldn't do it because he was shooting Steven Spielberg's Hook. Both men were known for improvising, and you can feel the room the role leaves for it.
Under the comedy sits a serious problem. Penthara IV is freezing under the dust of an asteroid strike, and every fix the Enterprise tries makes things worse. The last option could save the planet or strip away its atmosphere and kill about 20 million people, and the one man aboard who might know how it turns out says he can't tell.
That scene between Picard and Rasmussen is the one to watch. Picard asks what happens if one of the lives he saves is a child who grows up to be "the next Adolf Hitler or Khan Singh," and Patrick Stewart plays the whole argument straight. The A.V. Club thought the planetary crisis was the stronger story and almost deserved to be the main one.
A man out of his time
Picard goes ahead with the plan, and it works. He tells Rasmussen that the refusal only strengthened his belief that the choice was his to make, and Rasmussen apologizes, sincerely or not.
Inside the pod, Data finds a tray of Enterprise property, from a padd and a tricorder to the neural stimulator Rasmussen talked out of Dr. Crusher. Rasmussen holds a phaser on him, but it won't fire: the Enterprise's sensors disabled it when the pod opened. Rasmussen is not from the 26th century at all. He is a frustrated inventor from 22nd-century New Jersey who stole the pod, which really does come from the future, and planned to take 24th-century technology home and pass it off as his own.
Worf takes him into custody, and the pod's automatic timer kicks in. It vanishes on its own, and Rasmussen is left stranded three centuries from home, facing a cell in a future he only wanted to rob. Frewer later joked he was "still floating around up there in space, rotting in jail."
Behind the scenes
- With Robin Williams busy on Hook, the part went to Frewer, who said it came to him as an offer. He liked playing a man who "appeared likable but was really nefarious underneath it all," and joked about the name: "Anything that's over 17 syllables, I'm into it."
- The episode won the Emmy for Individual Achievement in Special Visual Effects. "Conundrum" won a second Emmy in the same category that season.
- Rick Berman has the sole writing credit. It is also the first of five appearances by Ensign Felton at the conn.
- Rasmussen didn't stay in jail in the books. He turns up at a poker tournament on Deep Space 9 in The Big Game, and he has a big part in David A. McIntee's novel Indistinguishable from Magic.
The thread
The oldest rule of time travel stories, an earlier visit from the future, and the books that gave Rasmussen a life afterwards.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Where it led
DNA strand
Time Loops & Timelines
The hour hangs on whether a visitor from the future should tell you how things turn out. Picard asks, gets no answer and has to choose anyway, and the episode is firmly on his side.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Read · Short story
A Sound of Thunder by Ray Bradbury
The short story every "don't touch anything in the past" argument comes back to. A few pages, and you'll see why Rasmussen is so nervous.
Watch · Star Trek
"The City on the Edge of Forever" (1967)
If Picard's argument about saving lives that history may not want saved stayed with you, this is the original series taking it as far as it goes.
Watch · Star Trek: TNG S3
"Captain's Holiday" (1990)
More time travelers who know more than they say, with Picard on vacation and not enjoying it.
Read · Novel
Indistinguishable from Magic by David A. McIntee
If you wanted more of Rasmussen, he has a big part in this Star Trek novel.
Sources
- “A Matter of Time (Star Trek: The Next Generation),” Wikipedia
- “Star Trek: The Next Generation season 5,” Wikipedia
- Keith R.A. DeCandido, “Star Trek: The Next Generation Rewatch: "A Matter of Time",” Reactor, 2012
- Zack Handlen, “Star Trek: The Next Generation: "A Matter Of Time"/"New Ground",” The A.V. Club, 2011
- “Interview: Next Gen Guest & Sci-Fi Favorite Matt Frewer,” StarTrek.com, 2013