Red Dwarf / Series X / Episode 2

Fathers & Suns

Lister is his own father, so every year he sends himself a Father's Day card. This year Rimmer tells him he's been a lousy dad, just as the ship gets a new computer that knows what you'll do before you do it.

  • Aired Oct 11, 2012 · Dave
  • Directed by Doug Naylor
  • Written by Doug Naylor
  • Starring Chris Barrie, Craig Charles, Danny John-Jules and Robert Llewellyn
Still from Red Dwarf, "Fathers & Suns"
Still from Red Dwarf, "Fathers & Suns"
Image via TMDB · 1 of 2
Red Dwarf, "Fathers & Suns" (Dave, 2012). Image via TMDB.

More from the episode

The story in 5 beats

  1. A card to himself

    Every Father's Day, Lister writes himself a card, then drinks enough that he forgets he wrote it.

  2. Tough love

    Rimmer says Lister has been a poor father to himself. Lister records a drunken video scolding his "son," and the Medi-Bot opens a file on Dave Lister Jr.

  3. Meet Pree

    Rimmer and Kryten install Pree, a computer that predicts what the crew will say and do. Then she starts acting on her predictions.

  4. Course for the sunSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Drunk Lister has resigned. With no crew, Pree decides the ship has no mission, and anti-pollution rules send it into the nearest sun.

  5. Dave Lister Jr.Spoiler · tap to reveal

    Lister argues he's the son, so the mission stands. And since he means to uninstall Pree, she should see that coming and switch herself off.

Why it still matters

Series VII's "Ouroboros" left Lister with the strangest family tree in sitcom: he is his own father, with Kochanski as his mother. Doug Naylor's episode takes that knot seriously enough to ask whether, as his own dad, Lister has been any good at the job. The title is a nod to Ivan Turgenev's 1862 novel Fathers and Sons.

The other half of the episode gives the ship a new computer. Holly had been offline since water damage, as the crew said in Back to Earth, and Rimmer and Kryten install Pree, played by Rebecca Blackstone. Pree predicts conversations so accurately that having them becomes pointless, and she does the same with repairs, carrying out the mistakes she knows Rimmer is about to make.

Craig Charles had flu during filming, which helped the hangover scenes. The plot was complicated enough that it was briefly considered as the series opener before "Trojan" kept its slot.

Spoilers from here on. This is where Lister uses his own paradox as a loophole.

Beating a computer with a family tree

Drunk Lister has resigned his post, so Pree starts withdrawing his privileges, oxygen included. He ends up shot out of an airlock in a spacesuit and makes his way back while Pree, reasoning that a ship with no crew has no mission, sets Red Dwarf on course for the nearest sun.

The Medi-Bot's records now show a Dave Lister Jr., and Lister claims to be him: Senior quit, Junior didn't, so the mission is still valid. Then he tells Pree he plans to uninstall her. A computer that acts on what it predicts should see that coming, so she shuts herself down.

In the coda Lister turns down the freebies given to new crew members because he has to study for a Robotics Training Programme. He abandons the studying as soon as he finds a new video game among them.

Behind the scenes

  • It was recorded on 23 December 2011 at Shepperton Studios, the second episode of the series in the studio.
  • Because the plot was so involved, it was briefly considered as the series opener. "Trojan" kept its slot.
  • Craig Charles had flu during filming, which made the hangover scenes more convincing.
  • Kerry Shale plays both the Medi-Bot and Taiwan Tony, whose catchphrase "it very strange question" comes from the spoof Japanese game show Banzai.
  • Rebecca Blackstone, who plays Pree, also voices one of the vending machines in the "Chinese whispers" scenes, without a credit.
  • The ramscoop at the front of Red Dwarf is labelled on screen for the first time. The name comes from the novels.
  • It drew 1.6 million viewers on Dave.

The thread

A paradox from Series VII meets a very old idea in science fiction: the ship's computer that takes its rules more seriously than its crew.

Came before

Shares DNA with

Left its mark on

DNA strand

Time Loops & Timelines

Lister's existence is a closed loop, and here it turns into a domestic problem: cards, guilt, and a medical file for a son who is also the father. The paradox "Ouroboros" left behind ends up driving the plot.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"Ouroboros""Future Echoes""Stasis Leak"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Red Dwarf VII

"Ouroboros" (1997)

If Lister's family tree made your head hurt, this is the episode that planted it, and you'll see how much this one builds on it.

Watch · Red Dwarf II

"Queeg" (1988)

The show's first replacement computer, Pree's ancestor, is a stern one, and the crew miss Holly fast.

Watch · Film

2001: A Space Odyssey (1968)

The serious version of a ship's computer that follows its logic to the letter, whatever the crew think about it.

Read · Novel

Fathers and Sons (1862)

Turgenev's novel about a generation gap gave the episode its title. Lister's version has the gap inside one man.

Sources