
The story in 5 beats
- Once more unto the holodeck
Data performs a scene from Shakespeare's Henry V on the holodeck. One of the soldiers looks oddly familiar.
- A clerk on the run
The Enterprise rescues a Romulan scout ship. Its pilot, Setal, warns of a secret base on Nelvana III but won't give evidence.
Who he really isSpoiler · tap to reveal
Data shows Setal a holodeck Romulus. He dismisses it, and admits he is Admiral Jarok, a man with a bloody record against the Federation.
Nelvana IIISpoiler · tap to reveal
Picard crosses the Neutral Zone to see for himself. There's no base, and two warbirds decloak around the Enterprise.
A letter homeSpoiler · tap to reveal
Tomalak demands surrender, and Picard has a surprise of his own. Jarok is left with nothing to go home to.
Why it still matters
A small Romulan scout ship races across the Neutral Zone with a warbird on its tail. The Enterprise steps in, the warbird turns away, and the pilot, a self-described logistics clerk called Setal, says the Romulans are building a base on Nelvana III, a base that could support a large fleet. He won't offer proof. Picard has to choose between a possible war and a possible trap.
Ronald D. Moore wrote it, only his second script for the show, and he described it as the Cuban Missile Crisis in space. It plays like a Cold War thriller: almost all talk, every scene a little negotiation about trust. James Sloyan is superb as the Romulan, proud and frightened at once, and Andreas Katsulas is back as Tomalak, as smug as ever.
Critics love it. Keith DeCandido at Tor.com gave it 9 out of 10 and said "everything in this episode works"; Zack Handlen at The A.V. Club gave it an A. It opens with Data performing Henry V on the holodeck, the night before a battle, which sets the mood for everything after.
The pawn
Jarok wasn't lying. His own side fed him false information about Nelvana III, so his defection would lure a Federation ship across the Neutral Zone and into an ambush. Tomalak is waiting with two warbirds and demands that Picard surrender. Picard calmly lets three Klingon Birds-of-Prey, invited along at his request, decloak beside him. The standoff ends in stalemate. The Romulans withdraw, and so does the Enterprise.
Jarok defected to protect his family from a war he thought was coming, and now he can never see them again. He takes his own life, leaving a letter for them. Data notes that it can't be delivered. Picard says that as long as there are Romulans with Jarok's courage and conviction, one day it might be. Handlen called it "a dark, dark episode" and credited Moore for refusing to soften it with a happy ending, though the last line leaves a little hope.
Behind the scenes
- Ronald D. Moore's first sale to the show was "The Bonding." This second script got him a staff job, and he stayed through the final season, then went to Deep Space Nine and co-wrote Star Trek Generations and Star Trek: First Contact.
- The first draft had Data playing Sherlock Holmes. Rights trouble with the Conan Doyle estate ruled that out, and Patrick Stewart suggested Henry V instead.
- Stewart, a Royal Shakespeare Company member, asked to play the soldier Michael Williams under heavy prosthetics, and gave him a strong Black Country accent from the area around Birmingham and Wolverhampton.
- Nelvana III is named after Nelvana, the Canadian animation studio.
- It's the first mention of the Treaty of Algeron.
- James Sloyan went on to play the title role in Voyager's "Jetrel."
The thread
A Cold War standoff in space, framed by Shakespeare's night before battle.
Came before
Shares DNA with
Where the writer went next
DNA strand
Us vs. Them
The Federation and the Romulans look at each other across a line, each sure the other is planning something. Jarok crosses it on purpose to stop a war, and finds his own government was counting on him to start one. The standoff ends with nobody firing, and the most decent person in it is the enemy admiral.
Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.
If this one stayed with you
Where to go next, and why.
Watch · Film
The Hunt for Red October (1990)
Our pick if you liked the question at the heart of this one: a defector, a lot of nervous officers, and no easy way to check his story.
Read · Novel
The Spy Who Came in from the Cold — John le Carré
If Jarok's last scenes stayed with you, le Carré's Cold War classic is about a man and the people on his own side who used him.
Watch · Film
Henry V (1989)
Our pick for the whole play, including the night-before-battle scene Data performs.
Watch · Star Trek: TNG S3
"The Enemy" (1989)
Tomalak's first round with Picard, a few weeks earlier, with another Romulan stranded among enemies.
Sources
- “The Defector (Star Trek: The Next Generation),” Wikipedia
- Keith R.A. DeCandido, “Star Trek: The Next Generation Rewatch: "The Defector",” Tor.com, 2011
- Zack Handlen, “Star Trek: The Next Generation: "The Vengeance Factor"/"The Defector",” The A.V. Club, 2010
- James Hunt, “Revisiting Star Trek TNG: The Defector,” Den of Geek, 2014
- “Ronald D. Moore,” Wikipedia