Star Trek: The Next Generation / Season 7 / Episode 18

Eye of the Beholder

A happy young officer throws himself into a plasma stream for no reason anyone can see. When Troi visits the spot, she starts feeling what he felt.

  • First aired Feb 28, 1994 · Syndication
  • Directed by Cliff Bole
  • Teleplay by René Echevarria, from a story by Brannon Braga
  • Guest starring Mark Rolston
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Eye of the Beholder"
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Eye of the Beholder"
Image via TMDB
Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Eye of the Beholder" (Syndication, 1994). Image via TMDB.

The story in 5 beats

  1. The jump

    Lieutenant Kwan, working in nacelle control, leaps into the plasma stream. His friends and his girlfriend saw no sign of trouble.

  2. An empathic echo

    Troi is overwhelmed at the nacelle. Crusher suspects she's picking up an emotional imprint Kwan left behind.

  3. Eight years ago

    Troi sees the unfinished room at Utopia Planitia and a red-haired man. He's Lt. Walter Pierce, now in Engineering, and Troi senses he's part empath.

  4. Behind the panelSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Geordi scans the wall Kwan was working on and finds a skeleton. Troi now suspects Pierce of murder, and Worf seems more interested in Kwan's girlfriend.

  5. Back at the catwalkSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Jealous and furious, Troi shoots Worf and runs to jump herself. A living Worf pulls her back, and only seconds have passed.

Why it still matters

It opens with a death that makes no sense. Lieutenant Daniel Kwan, by every account content and in love, climbs into the warp nacelle and jumps into a plasma discharge, saying "they were laughing at me." Troi and Worf investigate, and the moment Troi climbs up to the catwalk, she's flooded with panic and fear that aren't hers.

What follows is a ghost story told in Trek terms. Troi starts seeing the room as it was eight years earlier, while the ship was being built at the Utopia Planitia yards: a frightened woman, a staring man, a couple laughing. Troi and Worf's budding attraction gets its biggest scenes yet, and that puts a personal edge on the investigation.

The look of the place helps. This is the first time any Star Trek series or film went inside a starship's warp nacelle, and the narrow catwalk over the glowing plasma does a lot of the mood work.

Spoilers from here on. What Troi really saw, and what happened eight years ago.

Someone else's jealousy

Much of the episode happened inside Troi's head. From her return to the nacelle with Worf, she was living through a vision, and the jealousy that drove her to shoot him and run for the plasma stream belonged to Pierce. Back in the real nacelle, Worf stopped her at the edge, and only seconds had gone by.

The records fill in the rest. Pierce, the woman, Marla Finn, and the man she was seeing all died eight years earlier at Utopia Planitia in a plasma discharge. Troi's reading is that Pierce found out about the affair, killed them both, set off the discharge to hide it and took his own life. Being part empath, he left his feelings in that room, strong enough to reach Kwan years later and nearly Troi too. When Worf asks who killed him in her vision, she answers, "Hell hath no fury like a woman scorned."

Behind the scenes

  • Brannon Braga came up with the story and René Echevarria wrote the teleplay.
  • The nacelle interior was a first for the franchise, and the only one until Star Trek: Enterprise's "The Catwalk" in 2002.
  • Nora Leonhardt, usually Marina Sirtis's stand-in, plays Marla Finn without a line of dialogue. Since she couldn't also double for Sirtis, second assistant director Arlene Fukai did.
  • Mark Rolston, a character actor known for tough, unpleasant roles, plays Pierce.
  • Troi mentions having talked to Kwan during the crew evaluations seen in "Lower Decks." The Utopia Planitia shipyard was first mentioned in "Booby Trap."
  • Data tells Geordi that he once considered a form of suicide after he was first activated.

The thread

A feeling that outlives the people who had it, soaked into the walls of a ship.

Came before

The Mourning BrideWilliam Congreve · play · 1697 · the play behind the famous line Troi misquotes

Shares DNA with

"I Only Have Eyes for You"Buffy the Vampire Slayer · 1998 · an old tragedy replayed through the living; the Women at Warp podcast compared the two
The ShiningStephen King · novel · 1977 · a psychic who picks up the violence a building remembers

DNA strand

Is Any of This Real?

Troi's gift is reading other people's feelings, and the episode turns it against her: she can't tell which emotions are her own. The longer she investigates, the less sure she or we can be about what's happening.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:The Shining"I Only Have Eyes for You"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Buffy the Vampire Slayer

"I Only Have Eyes for You" (1998)

If the idea of an old, unfinished tragedy using the living to play itself out again got under your skin, Buffy did it with a 1950s school dance.

Read · Novel

The Shining by Stephen King

A boy who senses what people feel, in a hotel full of old violence. Troi would recognize the problem.

Watch · TNG S7

"Parallels" (1993)

Where the Worf and Troi pairing first came up, in a Brannon Braga story with a lot more Worfs in it.

Sources