Star Trek: The Next Generation / Season 5 / Episode 14

Conundrum

An alien scan wipes the crew's memories. They still know how to fly the ship, but nobody knows who's in charge, who they are, or why they're at war.

  • First aired Feb 17, 1992 · Syndication
  • Directed by Les Landau
  • Story by Paul Schiffer
  • Teleplay by Barry Schkolnick
  • Guest starring Erich Anderson, Michelle Forbes and Liz Vassey
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Conundrum"
Still from Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Conundrum"
Image via TMDB
Star Trek: The Next Generation, "Conundrum" (Syndication, 1992). Image via TMDB.

The story in 5 beats

  1. Scanned and blank

    An unknown ship scans the Enterprise. The whole crew loses their memories, and the computer's files are partly erased.

  2. Who's in charge?

    Worf takes command on the strength of his sash. Data is taken for the bartender. The files restore names, and a man named MacDuff is listed as first officer.

  3. Riker and Ro

    With no memory of their feud, Riker and Ro Laren fall for each other.

  4. Orders to destroySpoiler · tap to reveal

    The computer says the Federation is at war with the Lysians and orders a strike on their command. The first Lysian ship is easily beaten.

  5. The strangerSpoiler · tap to reveal

    Picard refuses to fire on defenseless people. MacDuff tries to fire himself, and Riker and Worf bring him down.

Why it still matters

A strange ship scans the Enterprise, and every person aboard forgets who they are. Skills survive: people can still read a console or fire a phaser. Names, ranks and history are gone, and the computer's personnel files are partly wiped too. The computer says there's a war on with the Lysians, and the Enterprise has orders to strike deep into their space.

Half the fun is watching the crew rebuild themselves from scratch. Worf decides his sash probably means he's in charge and makes a shipwide announcement. Data was standing behind the bar in Ten Forward, so Troi assumes he's the bartender. Riker and Ro Laren, who can't stand each other, have no memory of that and get along very well indeed.

The other half is about orders: what a captain does with commands he has no memory to check against. The A.V. Club's Zack Handlen gave it a B+, and in 2020 Screen Rant ranked it the 14th best TNG episode, saying it "gave viewers a chance to know the characters a bit more."

Spoilers from here on. From here, who MacDuff really is.

The man nobody remembered

Kieran MacDuff, the first officer nobody could place, was never part of the crew. He's a Satarran, a species at war with the Lysians, and the scan, the wiped files and the war orders were all his work. The Satarrans wanted the Enterprise as a weapon to win their war for them.

What saves everyone is Picard's character, which survives without his memories. He sees that the Enterprise far outclasses the enemy and refuses to fire on defenseless people. MacDuff knocks Worf aside to fire the weapons himself, and Riker and Worf's phaser fire breaks through his disguise. Picard apologizes to the Lysians, Crusher restores everyone's memories, and in Ten Forward Troi and Ro tease Riker about the last few days.

Behind the scenes

  • "Conundrum" shared the Emmy for Outstanding Special Visual Effects with another TNG episode, "A Matter of Time".
  • Keith R.A. DeCandido reports that Joe Menosky wrote most of the teleplay but chose not to be credited, so Barry Schkolnick got the credit and the payment.
  • The personnel files reveal Crusher's birth name, Howard, which "Sub Rosa" later picks up. They also give Troi's father as "Alex", though "The Child" had called him Ian.
  • Riker plays "The Nearness of You" on trombone, the same song he played with the holographic jazz band in "11001001".
  • The Satarrans returned in the novels A Time to Sow and A Time to Harvest by Dayton Ward and Kevin Dilmore.

The thread

A crew that forgets itself, and a war it's told to fight.

Came before

Shares DNA with

The Bourne IdentityRobert Ludlum · novel · 1980 · our pick: a man with no memory who is very good at his job

DNA strand

Memory & Identity

Strip away everyone's memories and the crew's characters still show through. Worf reaches for command, Riker flirts, and Picard's conscience works fine without a past to lean on.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"Clues"MementoExplore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Star Trek: TNG S4

"Clues" (1991)

Another mystery built on missing memory, where the crew has to work out what happened to a day they can't remember.

Watch · Film

Memento (2000)

If you liked watching people piece themselves together from records, this film runs on the same idea.

Read · Novel

The Bourne Identity by Robert Ludlum

A man wakes with no idea who he is and finds his skills intact, just like the crew here.

Watch · Film

The Manchurian Candidate (1962)

The Cold War thriller about a man turned into a weapon, which Picard's worries here echo.

Sources