Red Dwarf / Series XII / Episode 1

Cured

Starbug limps into a research station where four of history's worst people have supposedly been cured of evil. Lister gets on suspiciously well with Hitler.

  • Aired Oct 12, 2017 · Dave
  • Directed by Doug Naylor
  • Written by Doug Naylor
  • Starring Chris Barrie, Craig Charles, Danny John-Jules and Robert Llewellyn
Still from Red Dwarf, "Cured"
Still from Red Dwarf, "Cured"
Image via TMDB
Red Dwarf, "Cured" (Dave, 2017). Image via TMDB.

The story in 5 beats

  1. Poker lessons

    Over a game of cards, Lister tries to teach the Cat a poker face. The Cat doesn't get it.

  2. A station worth robbing

    Kryten finds a research station to scavenge, and Starbug, steering badly, sets off for it through a sandstorm.

  3. Cured

    Professor Telford introduces four historical monsters, rebuilt from their descendants' DNA and treated for evil. Dinner is very polite.

  4. Torture roomsSpoiler · tap to reveal

    After an evening of friendship, the crew wake up in separate torture set-ups and have to fight their way out.

  5. The testSpoiler · tap to reveal

    A psychopath detector picks out two people: the Cat, and Telford. Then the Cat's poker face finally works.

Why it still matters

Series XII opens with a joke premise that could go badly wrong: a lab that has brought back Hitler, Stalin, Vlad the Impaler and the Roman empress Messalina and treated them for evil. Den of Geek's Mark Harrison thought the show "largely gets away with it," mostly because the episode puts the discomfort on Lister, who keeps finding the new, gentle Hitler likeable.

Craig Charles put it neatly in an interview: "I wasn't playing guitar with Hitler, I was playing guitar with who I thought was a cured Hitler." That jam session is the scene everyone remembers, and it nearly had a different song. The production wanted Toto's "Africa," but the publishers said no once they heard who would be playing it.

It's also the Dave-era show at its tidiest. Harrison found the pacing "much better than most of last year's episodes," and singled out one sight gag, Starbug landing badly with its broken steering, as reason enough to like it.

Spoilers from here on. Who the patient really is, and how the Cat settles it.

The doctor is the patient

The cured monsters were never the patients. They're androids, the station's caretakers, and Telford reprogrammed them. Telford himself is the real subject of the experiment and the real psychopath, and the test the crew run on everyone flags him (and, less worryingly, the Cat, for being selfish and vain).

Telford holds them at gunpoint but can't fly Starbug, so he offers to take the Cat with him if the Cat kills the others. The Cat asks for the gun and shoots Telford instead, then credits the poker face Lister spent the opening scene trying to teach him.

Harrison felt the android twist was telegraphed, since the show had used droid copies before. The Cat is what lands: the machine calls him a psychopath, and he turns out to be loyal, in his own self-interested way.

Behind the scenes

  • Recorded at Pinewood Studios on 12 February 2016, more than a year and a half before it aired. Series XII was shot in early 2016 back to back with Series XI and shared many of its sets and costumes.
  • The working title was "Here No Evil."
  • Toto's "Africa" was the first choice for the Lister and Hitler jam. Doug Naylor said the rights holders "all said no as soon as they heard, 'It's with Hitler,'" so they played "The Happy Wanderer" instead.
  • Ryan Gage, a long-time fan, contacted the Naylors on social media. The writers struggled to find him a part until Linda Glover suggested Hitler. Gage had played Alfrid in Peter Jackson's Hobbit films.
  • Gage is the third actor to play a version of Hitler on the show. Like Kenneth Hadley in Series IV's "Meltdown," he's playing a droid.
  • Early drafts reportedly made Professor Telford the real Hitler. The idea was dropped in later rewrites.
  • UKTV Play released it a week early, on 5 October 2017, before its Dave broadcast.

The thread

Red Dwarf has been putting history's villains on trial for laughs since the wax droids of Series IV.

Came before

A Clockwork OrangeAnthony Burgess · novel · 1962 · the classic story of a treatment that promises to cure a violent man

Shares DNA with

Look Who's BackTimur Vermes · novel · 2012 · Hitler turns up in modern Berlin and people find him oddly charming

Where Series XII went next

DNA strand

Sci-Fi Played for Laughs

The science is pure sitcom engine: a machine that cures evil, and another that detects it. What the episode does with them is old-fashioned comedy of embarrassment, with Lister charmed by the wrong person and the others appalled. The best joke in it is the detector's verdict on the Cat.

Every great sci-fi story is built from a handful of strands like this one. Each strand page explains how it works and traces it across shows, books and films.

Also in this strand:"Meltdown""Justice""Polymorph"Explore this strand →

If this one stayed with you

Where to go next, and why.

Watch · Red Dwarf IV

"Meltdown" (1991)

If a sweet Hitler was the part that stuck, go back to the wax droid version, where history's villains and heroes fight a war on a theme park planet.

Watch · Red Dwarf IV

"Justice" (1991)

The crew's first brush with a high-tech system for sorting the guilty from the innocent, and the Series IV episode Den of Geek saw as this one's closest relative.

Read · Novel

A Clockwork Orange (1962)

Anthony Burgess asks the serious version of the question this episode plays for laughs: if you can switch off someone's capacity for harm, is the person who's left still them.

Read · Novel

Look Who's Back (2012)

Timur Vermes drops Hitler into the present day and lets people warm to him, which is the same uncomfortable laugh as Lister's jam session, kept up for a whole novel.

Sources